State Agency Finds NYC Hasidic Yeshiva Is Failing To Provide its Students with “Substantially Equivalent” Secular Education


State Agency Finds NYC Hasidic Yeshiva Is Failing To Provide its Students with “Substantially Equivalent” Secular Education, Breaking Century-Old Education Law. Names Numerous Infractions.

Contact: Shira Dicker: s.dicker@yalfed.org
+1.917.403.3989 (via WhatsApp until 10/14)

October 13, 2022 (New York, NY) — In the middle of the Jewish festival of Sukkot, Yaffed —a non-profit organization whose mission is to improve secular education in Hasidic and Haredi schools — had a new reason to celebrate: a historic ruling by the New York State Education Department (NYSED) in the groundbreaking case of Weber v. NYSED.

Since its founding in 2012, Yaffed has been working to improve secular education in New York and beyond for Hasidic and ultra-Orthodox children and to ensure that city and state officials enforce a decades-old NYS education law — Section 3204 — which mandates that children who attend non-public schools receive education in a manner that is “at least substantially equivalent” to that of local public schools.

In 2019, Beatrice Weber, a mother of ten children raised and educated within the New York Hasidic community, and Yaffed’s newly appointed executive director, brought a lawsuit on behalf of her youngest child, then age six, alleging that the school — Yeshiva Mesivta Arugath Habosem (YMAH) – was failing to teach her son the secular subjects mandated by New York’s education law. Her lawsuit languished for years and was dismissed by NYSED, with the agency claiming that it did not have “jurisdiction” over the Yeshiva. Ms. Weber appealed and in June of this year Acting Supreme Court Justice Adam Silverman issued an historic opinion annulling
NYSED ’s dismissal and ordering it to complete its investigation of the Yeshiva by October 6, 2022.

Following the court’s order, last week, NYSED issued a “determination,” concluding that YMAH was not complying with the law’s substantial equivalency mandate. The ruling is the first time in New York State history that an agency has ordered change at a Hasidic boys’ Yeshiva. Specifically, NYSED found “that there was little evidence that instruction in such areas (math, science, English language arts and social studies) was regularly and meaningfully delivered to students.” In its ruling, NYSED also strongly rebuked the NY CDOE for its investigative techniques. Implied was a criticism of NYC Mayor Eric Adams, who has provided cover for failing Hasidic schools. Yaffed is committed to making sure that NYSED’s determination in Weber v. SED will have a broad impact, leading the way for other failing schools to improve their substandard quality of education.

“I could not have achieved this success without the support of Yaffed, and the vision and passion of its founder Naftuli Moster,” Ms. Weber stated. “Yaffed connected me with David Shapiro, who served as legal counsel for my lawsuit. David and Yaffed were invaluable, providing us with ongoing support and resources.”

Ms. Weber’s attorney, David Shapiro, stated that NYSED’s determination was remarkable for many reasons.

“Aside from being the first of its kind in New York State,” he said, “like all historic decisions in the Civil Rights movement (think Brown v. Board of Education), it tells a story that is not written in the pages of the decision. Everyone failed Beatrice: the school, the politicians and the agencies. It took an independent Supreme Court Justice to order action.”

For further information about this story or to request an interview with Ms. Weber or Mr. Shapiro please contact Shira Dicker at shira.dicker@sd-media.com or at +1.917.403.3989 (until 10/13/22) and 917.403.3989 thereafter.


Yaffed is a nonprofit organization founded by individuals raised within Hasidic and Haredi
communities and is committed to improving secular education within these schools. Visit
https://yaffed.org/ for more information.

Stay Informed.

Sign Up For Our News & Alerts
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

WordPress Image Lightbox Plugin

Send a Letter

It is imperative that the people who hold the power to affect change, do. And your voice can help inspire education officials and political players to take action. Click below to submit a letter to NYC Council Education Committee Chair Rita Joseph. 

Invite Us to Speak

Awareness is the first step to achieving change. Please invite us to speak at your synagogue, club, community, center, etc.

Join a Network

You’re invited to band together with a community of individuals from your own area of expertise or personal interest to help advance Yaffed’s mission drawing on your personal experience or professional interests. 

Follow Us

You’re not going to want to miss our content! We’ll keep you posted on everything from media headlines and political players’ stance on this issue, to the real-life stories of individuals who have attended Hasidic Yeshivas.


A gift to Yaffed goes a long way in instilling meaningful change. With your financial support we can: amp up our advocacy efforts, launch strategic new initiatives, expand our reach, and place extra pressure on the people who hold the power to move this issue forward. 


We’d love to send you the latest news and information coming from Yaffed. Enter the following information below to be added to our mailing list of regular updates:

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

join a network of lawyers, educators, communal leaders, and others

  • Please let us know your availability to appear in person or virtually at events in which we need members of the public to speak out.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.